When to choose a holistic rubric So, when might you use a holistic rubric? Rubric can be based on relevant developmental theory. The audience can identify the central purpose of the student work without little difficulty and supporting ideas are present and clear.
For example, what level would you assign a student on the holistic research rubric above if the student included 12 sources, had lots of inaccuracies, did not make it clear from which source information came, and whose bibliography contained most relevant information?
Performance on that criterion could be judged along three levels of performance: Or, at the least, it is a place to start. The audience is easily able to identify the focus of the student work which is supported by relevant ideas and supporting details.
Information is presented in a logical manner that is easily followed. Disadvantages of Holistic Rubrics Does not provide specific feedback for improvement.
Also, it is not true that there must be an even number or an odd number of levels. As student performance increasingly varies across criteria it becomes more difficult to assign an appropriate holistic category to the performance. Alternatively, if two criteria are nearly inseparable, the combination of the two can be treated as a single criterion in an analytic rubric.
It becomes more and more difficult to assign a level of performance in a holistic rubric as the number of criteria increases. For example, in an oral presentation rubric, amount of eye contact might be an important criterion.
So, some educators believe a holistic or global assessment of student performance better captures student ability on certain tasks. There are no more than two mechanical errors or misspelled words to distract the reader. Again, that will depend on the situation.
Holistic Rubrics A holistic rubric consists of a single scale with all criteria to be included in the evaluation being considered together e. Making distinctions in student performance across two or three broad categories is difficult enough.
Furthermore, you might discover that the labels of never, sometimes and always sufficiently communicates to your students the degree to which they can improve on making eye contact.
On some tasks it is not easy to evaluate performance on one criterion independently of performance on a different criterion. In contrast, number of sources is considered along with historical accuracy and the other criteria in the use of a holistic rubric to arrive at a more global or holistic impression of the student work.
Developing a developmental rubric requires a close tie between assessment criteria and the theory of development. Disadvantages of Developmental Rubrics Conceptually, this type of rubric is more difficult to design. Begins to explore how social systems affect group norms and intergroup relations Capacity to engage in meaningful, interdependent relationships with diverse others that are grounded in an understanding and appreciation for human differences; understanding of ways individual and community practices affect social systems; willing to work for the rights of other King, P.
When student work is at varying levels spanning the criteria points it can be difficult to select the single best description. But holistic rubrics can also be employed for more substantial assignments. How would you treat "historical accuracy" as more important a criterion in the holistic rubric?This article describes analytic and holistic rubrics and lists the advantages of each.
Using the descriptions, choose a rubric which fits your assessment needs and works best with your lessons and works best for your students. Appendix 3: Sample rubrics for assessment (a) Rubric for participation and group work.
It is also suitable for self-assessment and peer feedback. Adapted and used with permission from Karen Franker. For original click here. Adapted and used with permission from Teach-nology.
Sample Analytic Rubric: Oral Presentation Excellent Adequate Limited Poor Content The speech d emonstrates thorough and accurate knowledge of the subject matter.
The speech demonstrates accurate knowledge except in minor details. The speech demonstrates. Learn how to score a rubric and view samples of expository and narrative writing rubrics.
Plus: learn how to create a rubric from scratch by using this step-by-step guide, as well as view samples of informal and formal essay rubrics.
Learn more about rubrics and alternative assessments in our Online Courses, Online Certificate Programs, Writing Rubrics. Samples of Student Writing, Scored With a 6+1 Trait Rubric University of Wisconsin South Broadway St., Menomonie, WI 4 University of Florida Institutional Assessment – Writing Effective Rubrics For analytic rubrics, the criteria are usually listed down the left column with the descriptions of the levels of achievement across the rows for each criterion.Download